На підставі аналізу приписів чинного Кримінального кодексу
України, а також практики застосування його деяких положень виокремлено і вивчено регламентовані законом обставини, що виключають можливість застосування кримінальної відповідальності та інших заходів кримінально-правового характеру. Враховуючи отримані результати, сформульовано власні узагальнюючі висновки.
On the basis of the analysis of the regulations of the current Criminal Code
of Ukraine and the practice of implementing its certain provisions the author has
distinguished and analyzed regulated by the law circumstances precluding possibility
of implementing criminal liability and other measures of criminal and legal nature, and
on this basis has formulated own generalizing conclusions.
It is noted that the circumstances, which preclude the application of criminal
liability and other measures of criminal and legal nature, are instances regulated by
the Criminal Code Ukraine, when, if they are present, it is impossible or not permitted
to use criminal liability and some punitive and non-punitive measures of criminal and
legal nature.
It is emphasized that punitive measures of criminal and legal nature (various
types of penalties) are always realized within such a complex social phenomenon as
criminal liability. However, non-punitive, but compulsory or incentive measures or those
that are based on humanistic principles and irrationality of implementing criminal
proceedings, can find their realization both within the criminal liability (p. 4, 5 of the
Art. 74, Articles 75, 79, 80, 81, 84, c. 2, p. 1 of the Art. 93, 96, Articles 967–969, p. 1 of the
Art. 105) and out of its limits (the Art. 17, p. 1, 2 of the Art. 31, Articles 36–43, 45–49,
c. 1, p. 1 of the Art. 93, the Art. 965, p. 1, 2 of the Art. 97).
In this regard the author has noted that criminal liability is precluded under
the current Criminal Code of Ukraine in cases if: 1) a person is in the condition of
irresponsibility while committing socially dangerous offense under the Criminal Code
of Ukraine (p. 2 of the Art. 19 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine); 2) committing an act
similar to a criminal offense (Articles 36–43, p. 1 of the Art. 433); 3) there is the presence
of voluntary refusal of committing criminal offense at the stages of previous criminal
activities (the Art. 17, p. 1, 2 of the Art. 31 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine); 4) there is unconditional exemption from criminal liability (Articles 45, 46, 48, 49 of the Criminal
Code of Ukraine); 5) implementing some requirements of the Constitution of Ukraine
(p. 1 of the Art. 61, p. 1 of the Art. 63), which are reflected in p. 2 of the Art. 7, p. 2 of the
Art. 385, p. 2 of the Art. 396 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine; 6) there is the presence of
diplomatic immunity (p. 4 of the Art. 6 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine).
The group of circumstances that preclude the applicability of certain measures of
criminal and legal nature is represented by the circumstances precluding the possibility
of using: 1) different types of punishments (p. 1 of the Art. 99, p. 3 of the Art. 56, p. 2 of
the Art. 57, Art . 58, p. 1 of the Art. 98, p. 3 of the Art. 60, p. 3 of the Art. 61, p. 2 of the
Art. 64 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine); 2) exemption from criminal liability under the
norms set forth in the Section IX of the General Part of the Criminal Code of Ukraine
(Articles 45, 46, 47, 48, p. 5 of the Art. 49 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine); 3) measures
of criminal and legal nature to legal enteties (Articles 963–969 of the Criminal Code of
Ukraine).
It is separately noted that criminal liability and the possibility of applying
exemption from criminal liability and punishment based on the requirements stipulated
by p. 1 of the Art. 97 and p. 1 of the Art. 105 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine are excluded
in case of committing socially dangerous acts by a person, who has not attained the age
of criminal liability (p. 2 of the Art. 97 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, Articles 498-502
of the Criminal Procedural Code of Ukraine).
На основании анализа предписаний действующего УК Украины, а также
практики применения его отдельных положений, выделены и изучены регламентированные законом обстоятельства, исключающие возможность применения
уголовной ответственности и иных мер уголовно-правового характера. Сформулированы собственные обобщающие выводы.
